Reddhott To get a Reddhott, first obtain a Taffly (make it a resident) then fly it through the flame of a Firebrand until it catches fire. Use the Watering can to extinguish the flames and the evolution process will take place. You can use any watering can, but make sure you catch it before the piñata extinguishes itself.

Candary To get a Candary, you must feed a Buttercup flower to a Sparrowmint.

Lackatoad To get a Lackatoad, feed a Nightshade Berry to a Lickatoad then hit it on the head with your shovel. Otherwise the Lickatoad will get sick.

Salamango To get a Salamango, feed a Chili to a Newtgat.

Zumbug To get a Zumbug, feed a Horstachio both a Blackberry and a Daisy.

Juicygoose To get a Juicygoose, feed your Quackberry a Gooseberry.

Twingersnap To get a Twingersnap, romance two Syrupents. Watch the egg, and right before it hatches it will bounce three times (do not get this confused with a regular egg jump) and on the third bounce, hit the egg with your shovel.

Fourheads To get a Fourheads, romance two Twingersnaps. Watch the egg, and right before it hatches it will bounce three times (do not get this confused with a regular egg jump) and on the third bounce, hit the egg with your shovel.