First Day [Flipendo, Potions, Dittany] (1 Pasty, 1 Frog):

• 3-star Flipendo learning.
• When entering Dungeons for Potions, go up past the Save Book, and you'll see a Pasty on the top-left of your screen.
• In Dittany, do Any% strats to get the Dittany, and on the way back, press the button near the moving platforms to start moving the platform below, go on that platform, and then search the bush on the left for a Frog.

First Night [Alohomora, Sneaky, Escape from Slytherin] (2 Pasties, 2 Frogs):

• 3-star Alohomora learning for a Pasty.
• Second floor of first sneaky, go up, get past the first Prefect, go left (there'll be a Prefect), get past the Prefect by going along the bottom wall, then go down and right to Alohomora a chest for a Frog.
• At the end of First Sneaky, in Fluffy's room, you'll see a hole above you. Go to the left side of the hole, and cast a Flipendo upwards and you should hit a Flipendo switch, rotating a beam that you can walk across. Alohomora a door. The pressure pads go around the room: left, right, top left, bottom, then top right, which is by the door. Go through the door and get a Pasty.
• In Escape from Slytherin, after going across the first moving platform, go left and Alohomora a chest for a Frog.

Second Day [Herbology, Quidditch #1] (3 Pasties):

• Going to Herbology, rather than going to the shortcut, on the 7th floor, go down past the statues of dolphins, and down-left to a Alohomora door. Hit the Flipendo switch through there and go up-left, and around the walls to the black hole 'doorway'. Go left in that observatory room to get the Pasty.
• Go down to the 5th floor (2 floors down). From the stairs, go left past a bookcase, and then up. Keep going up through the passageways, then up-right past the four pillars, and walk onto a pressure pad. Go back down to the bookcase, and you'll see two more pads. Walk on these, then go right, past the stairs, and up a bit to Alohomora another door. Go right, then left, then up and right to another pad. Walk on that, then go right to an open doorway. Defeat the firecrab for a Pasty.
• Before going into Greenhouse 1, go right and walk to the tree at the bottom to go into a secret area. Defeat all the enemies for a Pasty.

Second Night [Troll] (1 Frog):

• At Troll, fall down a hole. Go right, then up, and you'll go through a doorway to some spikes. Continue through the room, moving a barrel, and then open the Alohomora chest for a Frog.

Third Day [Avifors, Flobberworm, Lumos] (2 Pasties, 3 Frogs):

• 3-star Avifors learning.
• When going to Hagrid's Hut the second time, in the grounds, go down and left a bit until you see a row of statues with a circle of hedge. Avifors two statues next to each other to get through and get a Frog. (This is faster than doing it after Quidditch #3 by about half a second).
• When in the grasslands to Hagrid's Hut, nearing the end, when you'd usually go left past a bit of broken ground, go down to a couple of spiky bushes. Remove one of the bushes and go past and search the berry bush for a Frog.
• Opposite the spiky bushes is a small muddy patch 'under' the trees. Walk into the patch to go through a secret path to an area with an Alohomora chest. In that chest is a Pasty.
• In Flobberworm, in the top-right area, go up, then left past a few mushroom patches, and go into a hidden path through the trees. Search the bush in the secret area for a Frog.
• Back in the grounds, go down to Greenhouse 6 (watch for Prefects). A Pasty is here, and it's your only chance to get it.
• 3-star Lumos challenge.
• After Lumos, go up to the Common Room (use the shortcut on 4th floor). Go to the doorway at the top into the bedroom, and get a Pasty. This is the only chance you get.

Third Night [Wiggentree, Sneaky #2] (2 Frogs):

• In Escape after Wiggentree, after the room with a lot of broken floor, go right, then down-right, defeat a gnome or two, and Alohomora a chest for a Frog.
• In Sneaky #2, on the 5th floor, go right to do the intended route via the doorway. When doing all the moving platform stuff, there's an Alohomora chest on the way with a Frog in.

Fourth Day [Potions, Wingardium Leviosa, Quidditch #2] (2 Frogs):

• Going to Wingardium Leviosa, on the 2nd floor, go up-right, and to the left of Charms is an Alohomora mirror, with an Alohomora chest behind it with a Frog in.
• 3-star Wingardium Leviosa learning.
• After Wingardium Leviosa, go to the Dungeons, into the Potions room, go to the top and open a bookcase. Get through this room to get a Frog in a Alohomora chest.

Fourth Night [Library] (2 Pasties, 1 Frog):

• Before going into the Library, search the bookcase on the left of the doorway for a Pasty.
• In the Library, go left, then up, open the bookcase in the corner (without Lumos, you can see its silhouette), go left, Avifors a statue on a button, go into the hole near the button. Go right and up to get a Frog.
• After getting Flamel's book, you'll need to backtrack a bit. Search the middle bookcase of the three near where you get Flamel's book to get a Pasty.

Fifth Day [Quidditch #3, Forest] (1 final Pasty, 1 Frog)

• In the Great Hall, go up and then left. You'll see an Alohomora chest. Open it for a Frog.
• In the forest maze (after Unicorn), when getting to the area with two goblins and a large pond (right after the troll area), go to the bottom secret, move down-right and when you start moving to the right, move up-right. When you start moving upwards, hold up and you'll be in an area with doxies. Go to the top of the area and through the secret path to get a Pasty. You should now have 9 Health Bolts.

Fifth Night [The Stone Trials] (2 final Frogs):

• In Forbidden Corridor, after some spikes and gnomes, you'll see an Alohomora mirror above. Go through that and the room to get a Frog.
• In Devil's Snare, after getting the plant with the 7 moving platforms, go back, hit the Flipendo Block, then go right and down, left, up the first opening, go left and do the puzzle to get that plant (hit the Flipendo switch there), then go back out the opening, right, and up, and a door will now be open which leads to another plant and an Alohomora chest with a Frog in.

End:

• The last card (Harry Potter) is given to Harry in the final cutscene.
• If you got all House Points (and didn't lose too many), Gryffindor will win the House Cup.